1. Start
  2. Finance
  3. Guide

Does debt consolidation actually save money? Run these numbers first

A person working through bills with a calculator and a notebook
Photo by Jakub Żerdzicki on Unsplash

Debt consolidation means rolling several debts, usually credit card balances, into one new debt with a single payment. Done well, it lowers the interest you pay and gives you a clear end date. Done badly, it can cost more and leave you with the new loan plus fresh card balances. The difference is in the numbers.

Step 1: list what you owe today

For each debt, write down the balance, the APR and the minimum payment. Add up the totals. This is your baseline. Any consolidation option has to beat it on total cost, not just on monthly payment.

Step 2: compare the main options

Balance transfer credit card. You move card balances to a new card with a low or 0% promotional rate for a set period. Usually there is a transfer fee, often 3% to 5% of the amount moved. It works best if you can repay the balance before the promotion ends.

Debt consolidation loan. A fixed-rate personal loan pays off your cards, and you repay the loan in fixed installments. Compare the loan’s APR, including any origination fee, with the average rate on your current debts.

Home equity loan or line of credit. Rates can be lower, but your home becomes collateral. The CFPB warns that you could lose your home if you cannot repay, so this route deserves extra caution.

Debt management plan. A nonprofit credit counseling agency negotiates lower rates with your card issuers, and you make one monthly payment to the agency. Your cards are usually closed. This can help if your credit is too weak for a good loan or card.

Step 3: do the math

For each option, estimate:

  • the new monthly payment,
  • how many months to pay it off, and
  • the total cost, including fees and interest.

A lower monthly payment over a much longer term can cost more in total. If an option does not reduce the total or shorten the payoff, it is not saving you money; it only rearranges the debt.

Step 4: fix what caused the debt

Consolidation clears the balances on your old cards, which makes it easy to run them up again. Before you consolidate, build a budget, set aside even a small emergency fund, and decide what you will do with the old cards. Keeping them open but unused can help your credit, as long as the temptation is under control.

Know the difference: consolidation vs debt settlement

Debt settlement companies offer to negotiate with creditors to accept less than you owe, often while telling you to stop paying. The FTC warns that this can damage your credit, lead to fees, collection calls and lawsuits, and that forgiven debt may be taxable. Under federal rules, debt relief companies that sell by phone generally cannot charge fees before they settle a debt. Be wary of any company that asks for money upfront or promises to make debt disappear.

Where to get free help

A reputable nonprofit credit counselor can review your budget and options at little or no cost. Check that the agency is accredited and that counselors are certified, and ask about every fee before signing up.

The takeaway

Consolidate only when the numbers show a lower total cost or a faster payoff, and when you have a plan to avoid new debt. The best option is the one you can actually finish.

Sources

  1. What do I need to know if I'm thinking about consolidating my credit card debt? · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
  2. How to get out of debt · Federal Trade Commission

This guide is general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Rules, prices and availability vary by state and change over time. Check details with the provider or an official source before you decide.

Compare now