1. Start
  2. Finance
  3. Guide

Student loan vs personal loan: which to use for school costs and why it matters

Person sitting in front of a laptop
Photo by Christin Hume on Unsplash

When tuition, books or living costs leave a gap, there are two broad ways to borrow: a student loan, federal or private, or a general-purpose personal loan. They can look similar on a monthly payment, but they work very differently once you are repaying.

This guide explains the differences and the order in which most borrowers should consider them.

The short answer

For costs at an eligible school, federal student loans come first for most people, then private student loans, and a personal loan last. The reason is not only the rate. Federal loans include repayment options, deferment and forgiveness programs that no personal loan offers.

A personal loan is mainly worth considering for costs a student loan cannot cover, or for a course that does not qualify for student aid.

How each type works

Federal student loans

  • Made by the US Department of Education after you file the FAFSA.
  • Fixed interest rates set by law for each school year, the same for every borrower of that loan type.
  • No credit check for most undergraduate loans.
  • Repayment usually starts after you leave school, with income-based options and the possibility of forgiveness through programs such as Public Service Loan Forgiveness.

Private student loans

  • Made by banks, credit unions and online lenders.
  • Rates depend on your credit, or a co-signer’s, and can be fixed or variable.
  • Usually paid directly to the school and limited to the cost of attendance.
  • Some lenders offer in-school deferment, but protections vary by lender and are weaker than federal ones.

Personal loans

  • Unsecured installment loans for almost any purpose.
  • Money goes to you, not the school.
  • Rates and fees depend on your credit and income. Many lenders charge an origination fee.
  • Repayment typically starts within a month, even while you are still studying.
  • Terms are usually a few years, so monthly payments are higher.

Side-by-side comparison

Feature Federal student loan Private student loan Personal loan
Credit check Mostly no Yes Yes
Rate Fixed, set by law Fixed or variable, credit-based Usually fixed, credit-based
Payments while in school Usually none Often deferred Start right away
Income-driven repayment Yes No No
Forgiveness programs Yes Rarely No
Deferment and forbearance Set by federal rules Lender policy Rarely
Use of funds School costs School costs Anything

What changed for federal loans in 2026

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act changed federal student lending from July 1, 2026. According to a summary by Harvard’s financial aid office:

  • New loans made from that date can be repaid only under a new Repayment Assistance Program or a tiered standard plan.
  • Grad PLUS loans are phased out for new borrowers.
  • New annual and total limits apply, including $20,500 a year for graduate unsubsidized loans and a lifetime limit of $257,500 across federal loans, excluding Parent PLUS.
  • Parent PLUS loans are capped at $20,000 a year and $65,000 per dependent student.

The practical effect: more graduate students will hit federal limits and need private borrowing to fill the gap. That makes the comparison between private student loans and personal loans more relevant than before. Check studentaid.gov for the rules that apply to your loans.

Interest and the tax deduction

Interest on qualified student loans may be deductible on your federal tax return, up to a set annual limit and subject to income limits. Interest on a personal loan used for school generally does not qualify, because the loan was not taken out solely to pay education expenses. Ask a tax professional about your situation.

When a personal loan can make sense

  • Courses that are not eligible for student aid, such as some bootcamps or short certificate programs. Check first whether the school is eligible, and whether the program offers its own financing.
  • Costs outside the cost of attendance, such as moving or a car you need for a placement. Borrow only what you need and compare APRs.
  • A small, short-term gap you can repay within a year or two.

Even then, compare the APR and fees with a private student loan. Student loan lenders often offer lower rates and longer terms for the same borrower.

When it does not make sense

  • To pay tuition when you still have federal loan eligibility.
  • When you would need payments during school that you cannot afford.
  • When your work or career plan could qualify for federal forgiveness.

Refinancing: the other direction

Some borrowers consider turning student loans into a private refinance loan or personal loan later. Refinancing federal loans into a private loan permanently gives up income-driven repayment and federal forgiveness. Do it only if your income is stable and the saving is large.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a personal loan for college? Usually yes, but many lenders exclude tuition from approved uses, and you lose federal protections. Read the lender’s terms.

Which is cheaper? For borrowers with strong credit, a private loan rate can be lower than the federal rate. Cost is not only the rate, though: federal loans include options that can matter if your income falls.

Does a personal loan affect financial aid? It is not counted as aid, but any money you have saved can count as an asset on the FAFSA the following year.

Can I combine both? Yes. Many students use federal loans first, then a smaller private loan for the rest.

The takeaway

File the FAFSA and use federal loans first, compare private student loans next, and keep personal loans for costs or courses student loans cannot cover. Compare APR, fees and repayment terms side by side before borrowing.

Sources

  1. Federal Student Aid · U.S. Department of Education
  2. Changes to Federal Student Loans Made in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act · Harvard Student Financial Services

This guide is general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Rules, prices and availability vary by state and change over time. Check details with the provider or an official source before you decide.

Compare now