Landlord insurance vs homeowners: what changes when you rent out a home
A standard homeowners policy assumes the owner lives in the home. When you rent it out, whether you have moved out of your old house or bought a property to let, the risk changes: tenants live there, you are not on site to spot problems, and you depend on the rent. Most insurers expect you to switch to a landlord policy, sometimes called a dwelling or dwelling fire policy. Keeping a homeowners policy on a rented house can lead to a denied claim.
What landlord insurance covers
- The building and attached structures, against the perils listed in the policy.
- Other structures such as a detached garage or fence.
- Loss of rental income, often called fair rental value, if a covered event makes the property unlivable and the tenants have to move out during repairs.
- Liability for injuries on the property that are your responsibility, such as a fall on broken steps you failed to repair. Some basic dwelling policies leave liability out, so check.
- Your own property kept at the rental for its upkeep, such as appliances you provide, a lawnmower or furnishings in a furnished let.
What it does not cover
- Your tenants’ belongings. Tenants need their own renters policy. Many landlords require it in the lease, along with a minimum liability limit.
- Flood and earthquake, which need separate cover just as for homeowners.
- Wear and tear and maintenance problems.
- Short-term holiday rentals, which many standard landlord policies exclude or limit. If you let through holiday rental platforms, look for a policy written for that use.
Basic, broad and special forms
Dwelling policies come in levels that are often labeled DP-1, DP-2 and DP-3:
- DP-1 is the most basic, covering a short list of named perils such as fire and lightning, often at actual cash value.
- DP-2 adds more named perils and usually replacement cost on the building.
- DP-3 covers the building against all risks except those excluded, and is the closest to a homeowners HO-3.
The cheapest form may look attractive, but a burst pipe or theft-related damage might not be covered at all under a basic policy.
Setting it up well
- Insure the building for its rebuilding cost, not its market value.
- Choose a loss of rent limit that would carry your mortgage and costs for the months a major repair could take.
- Pick a solid liability limit, and consider an umbrella policy if you own several properties.
- Ask tenants for proof of renters insurance each year.
- Tell your insurer about changes such as a vacancy. Many policies limit cover if the property sits empty beyond a set period, often 30 or 60 days.
Costs and tax
Landlord insurance usually costs more than homeowners insurance for the same house, because the risks are higher. In the United States, premiums for a rental property are generally a deductible business expense; check with a tax adviser for your situation.
The takeaway
When tenants move in, move your insurance too. A dwelling policy with the right building limit, loss of rent cover and strong liability protects both the property and the income it produces.