1. Start
  2. Insurance
  3. Guide

Insuring a new driver: join a parent's policy or buy your own?

A young woman with both hands on the steering wheel of a car
Photo by Andraz Lazic on Unsplash

Inexperience is the biggest single risk factor in car insurance, so a new driver’s first policy is usually the most expensive one they will ever buy. The good news is that the price tends to fall steadily with every year of clean driving, and there are real ways to soften the first few years.

Option 1: add the driver to an existing household policy

For a teenager or student living at home, this is almost always cheaper. The household keeps its multi-car and multi-policy discounts, and the new driver benefits from the parents’ longer insurance history.

Things to know:

  • Most insurers expect you to list every licensed driver in the household, including teens with a learner’s permit in some states. Leaving someone off can cause a claim to be denied.
  • The household’s premium will rise, sometimes sharply. Ask the insurer to quote the new driver on the cheapest car in the household if your state and insurer allow you to assign drivers to vehicles.
  • A crash by the new driver goes on the shared policy and can raise everyone’s price at renewal.

Option 2: a separate policy in the new driver’s name

This makes sense when the driver owns and registers the car in their own name, lives elsewhere, or when the family wants to keep claims apart. It usually costs more, because the new driver has no history and no bundled discounts. Some insurers will not write a policy for a minor at all.

Discounts designed for young drivers

Ask about each of these by name, because they are not always applied automatically:

  • Good student discount for students who keep a qualifying grade average, usually a B or 3.0. You will need a report card or transcript.
  • Driver education or defensive driving course completion.
  • Student away at school, for students who study far from home without a car.
  • Usage-based or telematics programs that reward smooth braking, steady speed and limited late-night driving. These can suit careful new drivers well, but read how the program treats risky trips.
  • Safety features and the right car. A modest, safe used car with good crash ratings is far cheaper to insure than a powerful or expensive one.

Choosing limits and deductibles

It is tempting to buy the state minimum to keep the price down. But new drivers are statistically the most likely to cause a crash, and minimum liability limits are often well below the cost of a serious one. Families with a home or savings to protect usually choose higher liability limits and save money on the deductible instead. If the car is older and worth little, dropping collision cover may make more sense than cutting liability.

A checklist before the first solo drive

  1. Confirm the new driver is listed on a policy and on the right car.
  2. Check that proof of insurance is in the car or on a phone app.
  3. Review any graduated license rules in your state, such as passenger limits and night curfews. Breaking them can bring tickets that raise premiums.
  4. Agree on what happens after a crash: stay safe, call the police if needed, take photos and exchange details, and call the insurer promptly.

How the price changes over time

Premiums for young drivers typically fall as they gain experience and pass age milestones, as long as the record stays clean. Re-shop the policy every year or two, and again when the driver moves out, buys their own car or finishes school.

Sources

  1. What determines the price of an auto insurance policy? · Insurance Information Institute
  2. Auto insurance consumer guide · National Association of Insurance Commissioners

This guide is general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Rules, prices and availability vary by state and change over time. Check details with the provider or an official source before you decide.

Compare now

Latest updates

All updates →