1. Start
  2. Insurance
  3. Guide

How to compare pet insurance plans side by side

A dog and a cat lying in the grass
Photo by Andrew S on Unsplash

Two pet insurance plans with the same monthly price can pay out very differently on the same vet bill. The only reliable comparison holds the settings constant and then looks at the fine print.

Step 1: Fix the three settings

Ask every insurer for a quote with the same:

  • Deductible, and whether it is annual or per condition.
  • Reimbursement rate.
  • Annual limit.

If an insurer cannot match your settings, note the difference. A cheaper quote with a lower limit is not cheaper.

Step 2: Check how the bill is calculated

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) notes that plans can pay in different ways. Some reimburse a percentage of your actual bill. Others pay from a benefits schedule, a set amount per treatment, which may be less than your vet charges. Ask which applies, and whether the deductible is taken off before or after the percentage.

Step 3: Run one example bill

Take a realistic bill, for example $3,000 for surgery, and work out what each plan would pay. Then do the same for a chronic condition costing $1,200 a year for five years. Per-condition limits and per-condition deductibles show their effect here.

Step 4: Compare exclusions

  • Pre-existing conditions. NAIC explains that hereditary and certain medical conditions count as pre-existing, and incurable ones may be excluded or limited. Ask how each insurer treats curable conditions after a symptom-free period.
  • Hereditary and breed-specific conditions. Covered by some plans, excluded by others.
  • Both knees or both hips. Some plans exclude the second side if the first was a problem before cover began.
  • Exam fees, dental illness, prescription food, behavioral treatment. Often optional or excluded.

Step 5: Waiting periods

Plans have a waiting period for accidents, a longer one for illness and sometimes a much longer one for orthopedic problems. Write them down for each plan.

Step 6: Look ahead

  • How much do premiums typically rise with age?
  • Can the insurer reduce cover or add exclusions at renewal?
  • Is a condition claimed this year still covered next year?

Step 7: Service

NAIC suggests asking whether you can use any veterinarian and how long claims take to pay. Some insurers can pay the vet directly, which matters if you cannot cover a large bill up front.

A simple comparison table

Make a table with one column per insurer and these rows: monthly price, deductible type, payout on your example bill, annual limit, illness waiting period, hereditary cover, exam fees, premium at age ten.

The best plan is usually clear once it is on one page.

Check the company

Confirm the insurer or agent is licensed in your state. Your state insurance department can tell you, and it handles complaints.

The takeaway

Match the deductible, rate and limit across quotes, test each plan on the same example bills, and let exclusions decide between plans of similar price.

Sources

  1. Pet Insurance: It Could Save Your Pet's Life, Could Save You Money · National Association of Insurance Commissioners
  2. Pet Insurance · National Association of Insurance Commissioners

This guide is general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Rules, prices and availability vary by state and change over time. Check details with the provider or an official source before you decide.

Compare now

Latest updates

All updates →