Hiring a roofing contractor: quotes, red flags and what the contract should say
Most people replace a roof once or twice in a lifetime, so few know what a fair price or a good contract looks like. That makes roofing a common target for poor workmanship and outright scams, especially after a storm. A little checking up front avoids most problems.
Repair or replace?
A roofer should be able to show you why the roof needs replacing: widespread curling or missing shingles, granules in the gutters, soft decking or repeated leaks. A single leak or a few damaged shingles can often be repaired. If two roofers disagree, ask each to explain with photos.
Vetting a roofer
- License and registration. Rules vary by state and city. Check with your state’s licensing board where one exists.
- Insurance. Ask for proof of general liability and workers’ compensation cover, and call the insurer to confirm it is current. If an uninsured worker is hurt on your property, you could be liable.
- Local presence. A permanent local address and references from recent jobs nearby are good signs.
- Manufacturer certification can unlock longer material warranties.
Storm-chaser red flags
- Knocking on your door right after a storm and offering a free inspection.
- Pressure to sign today, or a “special price” that expires.
- Asking for full payment or a large cash deposit before work starts.
- Offering to “cover” your insurance deductible. In many states that is illegal, and it can be insurance fraud.
- Asking you to sign over your insurance claim payments before you have a written contract.
Comparing bids
Get at least three written estimates for the same scope. Each should state:
- The shingle or material brand and line.
- Whether old layers will be removed (a tear-off) and how damaged decking is priced per sheet.
- Underlayment, flashing, drip edge and ventilation work.
- Permits, cleanup, disposal and the start and finish dates.
A much lower bid often leaves something out. Compare line by line rather than on the total.
What the contract should say
The contract should repeat the scope, the total price, a payment schedule tied to progress, and who pulls the permit. It should include both the manufacturer warranty and a written workmanship warranty from the roofer. Keep deposits modest and pay the balance only after the job passes any required inspection and you have seen the finished roof.
If insurance is paying
Report storm damage to your insurer promptly and let their adjuster inspect. Your policy may pay replacement cost or actual cash value, and roofs are sometimes depreciated by age. Read your declarations page so you know your deductible and any separate wind or hail deductible.
The takeaway
Pick a licensed, insured, local roofer, compare detailed written bids, and never pay most of the price upfront. If a deal only works by bending your insurance claim, walk away.