1. Start
  2. Education
  3. Guide

Federal vs private student loans: which to borrow first and what to compare

Students working at computers
Photo by Dom Fou on Unsplash

Paying for college usually starts with free money, then loans. How you borrow matters as much as how much, because federal and private loans behave very differently if your income is low or something goes wrong after you graduate.

Start with free money

Fill out the FAFSA every year you are in school. It is the gateway to federal grants, work-study and federal loans, and many colleges and states use it for their own aid. Apply for scholarships and grants before you borrow.

How federal loans differ

Federal student loans are made by the U.S. Department of Education. Compared with most private loans, they offer:

  • Fixed interest rates set by law each year, the same for every eligible borrower.
  • No credit check for most undergraduate loans.
  • Income-driven repayment, which links payments to what you earn.
  • Deferment and forbearance options if you lose your job or face hardship.
  • Forgiveness programs such as Public Service Loan Forgiveness for eligible public and nonprofit workers.

Federal loan programs and repayment plans have changed in recent years, including changes taking effect in 2026. Check StudentAid.gov for the current limits and plans before you borrow.

When private loans come in

Private loans come from banks, credit unions and online lenders. They can fill a gap after federal aid, but:

  • Rates depend on your credit, so most students need a cosigner.
  • Rates may be variable and rise over time.
  • Repayment help in hardship is up to the lender and usually more limited.
  • They do not qualify for federal forgiveness programs.

A sensible borrowing order

  1. Scholarships, grants and savings.
  2. Federal subsidized loans, where interest does not build while you are in school.
  3. Federal unsubsidized loans.
  4. Private loans only for any remaining gap.

Comparing private loan offers

  • Compare the APR, not just the interest rate.
  • Choose a fixed rate if you want predictable payments.
  • Check fees, the repayment term and when payments start.
  • Ask whether the lender offers cosigner release and what happens if the borrower dies or is disabled.

The takeaway

Borrow federal first, then private only to fill the gap. Federal loans cost no more for most students and come with income-based payments and hardship options that private lenders rarely offer.

Sources

  1. Federal Versus Private Loans · Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education
  2. Student loans · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

This guide is general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Rules, prices and availability vary by state and change over time. Check details with the provider or an official source before you decide.

Compare now