1. Start
  2. Legal
  3. Guide

Child custody: how courts decide and when to hire a lawyer

An adult holding a baby's hand
Photo by Hu Chen on Unsplash

Custody law is set by each state, but the guiding principle is the same everywhere: the court decides according to the best interests of the child.

The types of custody

  • Legal custody is the authority to make major decisions. Cornell’s Legal Information Institute describes this as control over matters such as education, health care and religious instruction.
  • Physical custody is where the child lives.

Either can be joint, shared by both parents, or sole, held by one. With sole custody the other parent usually has visitation, also called parenting time, which can be supervised in some circumstances. The Legal Information Institute notes that many states presume joint custody is in the child’s best interests unless evidence shows otherwise.

Courts can also make temporary orders that apply while the case is in progress.

What best interests means

According to the Legal Information Institute, courts consider factors such as:

  • the wishes of the parents,
  • the wishes of the child, depending on age and maturity,
  • the child’s relationship with each parent, siblings and others in the household,
  • the child’s adjustment to home, school and community,
  • the mental and physical health of everyone involved.

Many states add factors such as each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent, and any history of domestic violence. Courts generally prefer to keep siblings together.

Parenting plans

Most custody cases end in an agreement, not a trial. A parenting plan sets out the weekly schedule, holidays, vacations, transport, how decisions are made and how disputes are handled. Many courts require parents to attempt mediation first. A judge still has to approve the plan.

Which state decides

When parents live in different states, the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act determines which state’s court has authority, usually the child’s home state. Moving a child to another state without agreement or a court order can seriously damage your case.

Changing an order

Custody orders can be modified, but you generally have to show a significant change in circumstances and that the change serves the child.

Preparing your case

  • Keep a calendar of the time you spend with the child and your role in school, medical care and activities.
  • Keep communication with the other parent civil and in writing.
  • Follow temporary orders exactly.
  • Do not involve the child in the dispute or speak badly of the other parent in front of them.
  • Gather school and medical records.

When to hire a lawyer

  • The other parent has a lawyer.
  • You disagree about where the child should live.
  • There are concerns about safety, substance abuse or neglect.
  • One parent wants to relocate.
  • More than one state or country is involved.

Family lawyers usually bill by the hour against a retainer. Some offer limited-scope help with a single hearing or document.

Free and low-cost help

Court self-help centers, listed by state through the National Center for State Courts, provide forms and guidance. Legal aid and bar referral services can be found through the American Bar Association’s Find Legal Help pages.

The takeaway

Focus on the child’s stability, document your involvement, try to reach a parenting plan and get legal advice early if safety or relocation is an issue.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Laws differ by state.

Sources

  1. Child custody · Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  2. Self-Help Resources · National Center for State Courts
  3. Find Legal Help · American Bar Association

This guide is general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Rules, prices and availability vary by state and change over time. Check details with the provider or an official source before you decide.

Compare now